Most Thais don’t eat pad Thai every day, but it’s still popular enough that it’s an ubiquitous street food in Thailand, and they don’t make it the way people usually do here.
Phat Thai is supposed to be boring as a base, but amp up to however you like with easily accessible condiments.
The only phat thai specialist in LA funnily enough is Pok Pok Phat Thai, and they pretty much do it just right. All of those elements are in it except for shell-on dried shrimp I think.
Otherwise, the one at Krua Thai that has been mentioned is good. Sanamluang does a decent one as well as they have the rep for being the place for good Thai noodles (At least late night).
If you’re in OC, Brad A. Johnson did a write-up of a place in Anaheim called Suthathip (second part of article). I haven’t tried it, but it may be worth looking into…
I’ll be staying downtown, so I’d be more interested in the places he’s referring to when he says “As good as anything in Thai Town.” He likes Night+Market’s as well.
Night + Market’s Pad Thai is the blandest version I have ever eaten. Noodles were made very al dente, and the rice flavor was the most dominant flavor in the dish since it is vegan and has no fish sauce, dried shrimp, pork fat or eggs. It’s the complete opposite of “hardcore” pad thai, especially compared to Pok Pok Phat Thai…
Sticky Rice in the GCM has a noodle-dedicated half of the restaurant. I’ve not been oddly enough, but they might do a solid pad thai.