Stoughton is a small community near Madison, WI, but it has a marvelous cheese shop. They have over 100 cheeses in the counter as well as cookies, an ice cream counter, buffalo sausage, and more.
It’s easy for locals to get there to get what they want but thankfully the owner ships pretty much anything across the country. I am partial to aged cheeses but there’s something here for everyone. Take a look: https://www.cheesers.com/cheddar_cheese_aged_10_years_p/chedwid10yr1lb.htm